Malaysia

Bukit Tabur forest clearing: outrage as law broken yet again

‘Never-ending’ issue facilitated by politicians’ apparent lack of will to get involved, says residents’ association head

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 12 Sep 2021 10:00AM

Bukit Tabur forest clearing: outrage as law broken yet again
The Selangor government has put a stop to forest clearing atop Bukit Tabur following public anger. – MOHD HAZLI HASSAN/The Vibes pic, September 12, 2021

by Isabelle Leong

KUALA LUMPUR – Images of forest clearing at Bukit Tabur in Selangor have set social media abuzz, with environmentalists, hikers and residents living nearby objecting to the activity.

Amid the outrage, the Ampang Jaya Municipal Council (MPAJ) has revealed that the land parcel in question is privately owned. 

MPAJ president Mohd Fauzi Mohd Yatim in a statement said the landowner has carried out clearing and tree felling without first securing approval.

The state government stopped the operation at 11am yesterday and seized an excavator used on-site. It has also placed a stone barricade to prevent heavy vehicles from re-entering the location.  

However, some questions remain. Will the state government approve any sort of development application for the said land in the near future? Will it purchase these plots from the owners in an effort to protect Bukit Tabur and the Klang Gates Quartz Ridge?

Residents of Taman Melawati, a nearby neighbourhood, are angry and disappointed over the clearing works carried out near a natural heritage site. 

Taman Melawati Residents’ Association chairman Azhari Taharim slams Bukit Tabur landowners who conduct open burning. – ALIF OMAR/The Vibes pic, September 12, 2021
Taman Melawati Residents’ Association chairman Azhari Taharim slams Bukit Tabur landowners who conduct open burning. – ALIF OMAR/The Vibes pic, September 12, 2021

Although it is privateers’ right to do whatever they desire with the land, Taman Melawati Residents’ Association (TMRA) chairman Azhari Taharim said he is seeing red as they are not following the law. 

“I am very angry because no one is following the law. If I own a plot of land there, I would have applied to MPAJ first. 

But they know that the law is not strict and the authorities can’t enforce it, so they bulldoze their way through first. If ever the authorities shut it down, they’ll just start applying for the formal papers.

“When it gets approved, they will do whatever they want,” Azhari told The Vibes.  

He condemned landowners for carrying out open burning at Bukit Tabur over the past few months.  

“As far as I’m concerned, I’m okay with them turning their land into orchards or farms, but not open burning. 

“Some may be rich enough to bring trucks and machinery up there to cut down trees and bring them down, but others burn. It makes the job quicker when they burn.”

Azhari, who visited the site with MPAJ officials, expressed grief that politicians appear to have no willpower or interest to get involved, let alone preserve the nation’s heritage.  

“The government should buy back the land, but it is saddening that there’s no one who has the political willpower to do so. 

(Datuk Seri Mohamed) Azmin Ali has not visited this area, not once. He even condones the development in Bukit Antarabangsa, but we are the ones fighting and opposing it. His name does not sell well here. He has never visited the place.”

Azmin has been Gombak MP for three terms.  

Taman Melawati Residents’ Association secretary Kennedy Michael says it is time-consuming to get the authorities on board to tackle the issue of forest clearing. – File pic, September 12, 2021
Taman Melawati Residents’ Association secretary Kennedy Michael says it is time-consuming to get the authorities on board to tackle the issue of forest clearing. – File pic, September 12, 2021

Kennedy Michael, who has lived in Taman Melawati for 44 years, said he is beyond annoyed that the activity keeps happening.

The TMRA secretary said every time such unethical practices take place, it breaks the association’s routine as it has to spend a lot of time gathering information and getting the authorities on board to tackle the issue.  

“Every time it happens, it’s annoying because there’s more work for us to do. We are not enforcers of the law. We are just a community of friends and environmentalists.

“When something like this happens, we spend a lot of time getting the authorities on board. 

It is definitely an annoyance at first, and there is despair because it never changes. You would imagine that people learn from their experience when something happens, and would know not to repeat it. But it’s never-ending.”

Resident Dr Sallehuddin Abdullah said he is shocked to know that forest clearing is still happening on the hill.  

The orthopaedic and spinal surgeon expressed hope for the government to be more transparent with the public when it comes to Bukit Tabur land ownership.

“We want to know exactly which plots are owned by the government or individuals.

“We also want comprehensive laws that state which plots can be cleared or cannot be cleared when it comes to development projects.”

Taman Melawati resident Dr Sallehuddin Abdullah wants the government to be more transparent on the matter of Bukit Tabur land ownership. – File pic, September 12, 2021
Taman Melawati resident Dr Sallehuddin Abdullah wants the government to be more transparent on the matter of Bukit Tabur land ownership. – File pic, September 12, 2021

He urged the government to gazette Bukit Tabur, as it is situated near the treasured Klang Gates Quartz Ridge. 

“When it comes to heritage, I feel that all the land involved should be gazetted and no development allowed there.

“Either the state or federal government should reacquire the land, especially when it comes to sensitive sites like Bukit Tabur.”

On Friday, Pertubuhan Pelindung Khazanah Alam Malaysia, a civil society group devoted to conserving nature, shared on Facebook photos showing a crane near the top of the hill in the middle of tiered clearings close to the Klang Gates Quartz Ridge.

Among the images is one showing garbage, presumably left behind by workers, at the site.

Following the furore, Selangor Menteri Besar Datuk Seri Amirudin Shari said the state government has nothing to do with the activity, and that the clearing works were not approved by local authorities.

“An enforcement team has gone to the site to stop the activity and seize machinery.” – The Vibes, September 12, 2021 

Related News

Malaysia / 3w

Johor polls should be contest of ideas, not division – Selangor PKR election director

Opinion / 3w

Ronnie Liu: What we should truly rejoice over is not the victory of any single party

Malaysia / 1mth

Selangor still Malaysia’s top economic engine, DOSM data counters political claims

Opinion / 1mth

Selangor must be wise: The people’s rice bowls must not be turned into sacrifices

Malaysia / 1mth

Selangor identifies seven deviant teachings in last five years

Malaysia / 1mth

New PJ hospital site finalised; 500-bed  facility planned - MB

Spotlight

Malaysia

After Johor, the uncomfortable question for Anwar’s critics: Were we too impatient?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Network School's business licences revoked, to cease operations tomorrow

Opinion

Orang Asli in Pahang: Token gestures or genuine recognition?

Malaysia

Tuition teacher sentenced to 105 years in prison and 70 lashes for raping daughter

Malaysia

Azam Baki denies involvement in RM178.29 million contract linked to brother’s company

Malaysia

Aminuddin urges NS voters to weigh manifesto promising benefits for M40 and B40 groups

Malaysia

No need to resign, PM has absolute power if there is doubt – Ahmad Zahid

World

Gaza’s water crisis deepens as families face thirst, disease and collapsing sanitation systems

You may be interested

Malaysia

Voters place greater emphasis on government performance than traditional political assumptions - INSAP

Malaysia

Federal Govt passes RM83.46m in flood mitigation, coastal protection projects to Selangor

Malaysia

Armed robber fails to steal RM82,000 from security van after guard’s quick action

Malaysia

Immigration tracks 19 Network School foreign nationals who 'vanished' from official records

Malaysia

Tengku Ampuan Pahang offers land to Orang Asli families affected by Sungai Cot land dispute

Malaysia

Dataran Merdeka filled with rubbish after World Cup final

Malaysia

Aminuddin urges NS voters to weigh manifesto promising benefits for M40 and B40 groups

Malaysia

PRNNS: Loke: 'We must win all 11 seats to help PH form state government'